milk in its coffee

Just over ten years ago I was at home (in St. Kitts) and I saw a mixed race looking womon standing in some residential area that I was driving through with my mother. I asked her who she was*, my mother said, she was probably Dominicana and that St. Kitts was now having some milk added to its coffee.

In the last ten-fifteen years this has changed significantly.

  • Children and grandchildren of Kittitians who left in the 1930s to work in the Dominican Republic in the sugar can industry are returning, some would say seemingly in droves. Of course like most places we claim that “these” people are here illegally completely ignoring their rights as citizens. Though many are dark-skinned and blend in until they speak revealing a Dominicana quite a few are “light skinned with nice hair”. They like all immigrants are being blamed for: stealing jobs from Kittitians by charging less than a Kittitian would
    • crime
    • eating up resources meant for locals e.g. education and health
    • and specifically for the women
      • “stealing” men from their wives
      • introduction of sex work (gigantic laugh)
  • Though this predates the fifteen years, there was a long history for Guyanese, most noticeably of Indian descent working on the sugar cane industry in St. Kitts. Their arrival too is accompanied by a similar narrative as above.
  • I remember the Chinese restaurant opening while I was still in secondary school. It was exciting. Now there are at least five restaurants and two supermarkets owned by Chinese nationals (whose numbers are increasing). Both of which are always packed with Kittitian people.
  • The opening of Port Zante (shopping complex on reclaimed land) has brought the opening of jewellery stores owned by Indians.
  • The university tourism which has increased dramatically with three at least off-shore US university setting up shot on the island sees an influx of European-Americans, Indian-Americans and a few African-Americans and Africans who stay far longer than any other tourist would typically stay.

The selling of our country to meet international debt has brought what was for at least me and unexpected; an uglier side to our people which reeks of our lack of love for ourselves and our fear of losing what little we have. For islands that claim to be melting pots the addition, appearance of people of who do not blend in to the predominant group may not be apparent. The implications however are grand. There are two grand ones I want us to consider. Racism and stereotyping are becoming increasingly common place in less theoretical ways. Discrimination against locals in favour of people who are perceived to have more money (read white) is rampant on a level we’ve never seen before. Our already warped sense of self as a result of the history of colonialism and now neo-colonialism is getting worse as what is attractive is now concretely and attainably light skinned with “nice” hair.

Immigration is challenging both for the newcomers and the people of the host country. For people of the host country, I implore you to deal with it. The same narratives that you employ for them- job stealing etc. are the same narrative others employ for the many of us that do leave to live and work elsewhere. These narratives erase personal histories, motivations and complex reasons for departure and arrival and instead only focus on privilege. I am in no way negating the privilege that many are exercising in being able to/having left their home countries but we cannot discount the challenges they face in moving to a completely new country.

Though we should not focus solely on the privilege we must acknowledge the advantage in being able to apply for economic citizenship, set up a business and move entire families. The seeming dogged work ethic which we envy (/use when it’s to our advantage e.g. construction) often puts as at a disadvantage to compete economically. Let’s not show our resentment to the people but lobby for our government to alter policies that privilege new nationals over locals. I know this is shaky ground but here I am talking about things like loans for local entrepreneurship and innovation versus caps on the number of non-nationals who can get citizenship.

I am doing my best not to read an anti-immigrant and instead as someone who recognises the need to support both local and immigrant communities. So for now I struggle with finding ways for thinking and acting through the increased milk in the coffee that aren’t hurtful to those who are there or those who have come/are coming/will come.

*For context, St. Kitts’s population is somewhere around 40 000 97% of which is of African descent, it’s the sort of place where people don’t  necessarily know everyone but you know of people, and know mutual people and where not being a person of African descent, or even a light-skinned person makes you stand out.

Comments on: "milk in its coffee" (3)

  1. […] Milk in its coffee, by derevolushunwidin […]

  2. Hi,

    I read this post through Soy’s blog carnival, and I loved it. So much to think about, and that resonates with me coming from an island (or island group) that has gone through all the issues associated with immigration. As a U.S. territory, the U.S. Virgin Islands has had both “immigrants” who came from the states from already privileged situations (this includes my family, by the way) and less privileged immigrants who came seeking work. It’s a sore spot to bring up that in a lot of cases people from other islands (including Kittians) were not treated especially well in the USVI, while many Stateside folks were coming with money already, and in a lot of cases today don’t really integrate into the society at all. Now that we are a few generations removed from the beginning of this process, I’m not sure if the situation is getting better or worse – and now of course we too have a large Dominican population added to the mix. There’s still a lot of insecurity in pretty much every segment of our society. Uneven development and prosperity is a situation we really have to address – especially when so many things that are native/local/indigenous are swept aside. Not sure if St. Kitts and Nevis would experience this the same way as the USVI, given obvious differences in political status (nation-state vs. territory). Anyway, I enjoyed reading this very much.

    All the best,

    • Even in writing the piece and thinking about intra-regional migration I was limiting it to people coming to St. Kitts and Kittitians going to the States. But the long history of Kittitians in the USVI is so obvious. I swear a quarter of my class was born in the USVI. When you tie all this up in nation/state hood and citizenship the complexities are mind-boggling. With everything we really need to be mindful and lived realities are mulitples.

      Thanks so much for commenting!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: